I'm starting the next one. Same size, 16 x 20 but this time I'm using hardbaord cradled with cheap michaels canvas stretcher bars and painted with Rublev Tempera Ground from Natural Pigments.
So far it seems really good. It goes on pretty smooth and creamy straight out of the jar. 3 coats was enough to cover thoroughly. I did some light sanding. Pencil doesn't clean up as easily as clayboard but it seems like a small price to pay since the texture is so much better. I haven't started painting yet so I can't say for sure but it seems much more like traditional gesso.
This the digital sketch
I'm sure it will change a lot by the time I'm finished. With that in mind I am not doing much drawing.
I will probably ink in some shadows.
I will let you know
May 23 note:
I have painted the first layers over everything. So far all the blue and green undercoat from yesterday have been lifting. I am hoping that it is just one of those things where I have to build up more layers and then it will adhere better. I had a similar (but different) problem with the clay board.
So note to myself: see if it and when it improves
May 29 update:
I'm so disappointed. I really wanted that stuff to work. It went on so easily and sanded nicely but when I tried to do the layering on the sky it kept lifting. I waited for layers to dry, I tried different amounts of egg etc. but it would not adhere. I finally tested it out on an old traditional gesso board and it worked right away.
I was suspicious for a while so I didnt actually get a lot of final painting done. I was still fiddling with the composition so I didn't really wasted too much painting time. Now I have to figure out the best way to gesso a 16 x 20 board as quickly as possible so I can continue. I might end up trying a smaller one.
April 2 2022 Update:
I haven't checked back here for awhile! I started again and finished on gessoed panel
The gesso does work better than the pre made stuff however as I am going along I am finding that regular illustration board (extra thick) is working just as well for my style. Also it gives me the option of using gouache and/or watercolors in some areas that I want more blendy. If I had this one to do over I would do the sky differently. See entry on "Fighting"